Leaked SSB4 Roster?

[jaklub]

Lack of Captain Falcon on that roster disturbs me.

Good thing it's not real

[dry]

Why would they choose Tails over Shadow? He's more popular, more iconic and already appeared as an assist trophy. Plus he would be easy to draw, considering he looks so much like a recoloured Sonic.

Oh, and Captain Falcon was dropped.

I don't believe it :\

[jaklub]

Aug 3, 2011 8:53:12 GMT -5 dry said:

Why would they choose Tails over Shadow? He's more popular, more iconic and already appeared as an assist trophy. Plus he would be easy to draw, considering he looks so much like a recoloured Sonic.

Shadow has a chance to be a half-assed clone of Sonic, Tails is more unique and has been around 9 years longer than Shadow.

[SmashKing201]

Thread needs to be locked. This is obviously fake for sure

[dry]

B: Gunshot
Side B: Motorbike
Up B: Chaos Teleport
Down B: Flame Ring
Final Smash: Chaos Control

If I can think of a unique moveset for Shadow, Nintendo definitely can.

[DGN]

full moveset pl0x

And really, too much STH references. Up B could be chaos teleport as you said. Side B is Chaos Spear. And I had thought of some unique thing a while ago where B is like Ness's down B, but instead of healing, it powers up down b for more range and damage. And Final smash would be chaos control as well.,


And I support Taelz for SSB4. Mainly because he'll FINALLY have a moveset that doesn't use anything from Sonic Battle.

[jaklub]

Aug 5, 2011 5:58:46 GMT -5 dry said:

B: Gunshot
Side B: Motorbike
Up B: Chaos Teleport
Down B: Flame Ring
Final Smash: Chaos Control

If I can think of a unique moveset for Shadow, Nintendo definitely can.

Nintendo could also think of an unique moveset of Ganondorf.

Hell, I think I'll just drop the argument of possibility of being a clone, they could make Tails a multi-jumping Sonic as well. I think that Tails is more probable mainly because of Sonic Colors (in Wii version of which he is the only recurring character next to Sonic and Robotnik), his early appearance and uniqueness only add to it. Back when Brawl was in development, Sonic 06 was the relevant Sonic game. Effect? We got Shadow as an Assist Trophy and Silver flying around Green Hill zone.
But, to judge that well, we need to wait till Sonic Generations is out.

And in before someone says "ogm sonec wont get 2 reps, dey hav to hav meguhmaen in!" or other "ogm hhrid partis hav to b onle snaek und sonec!": It's pretty much impossible to predict what will Nintendo do with third parties next time. They can remove them too

[SmashKing201]

I agree with Tails. I think he should come in before any other Sonic character to be a 2nd rep. He is Sonic's sidekick, and is the 2nd or 3rd most recurring character other than Sonic & Dr. Eggman.

[Chaotic Chao]

Tails > Shadow.
IMO.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Shadow>Tails
IMO.

Shadow is currently the second most popular Sonic character after Sonic himself, and while Tails has been demoted to sidekick lackey, Shadow has taken Tails' (and Kunckles') spot as the second main character. Granted, in latest games, Tails has been slowly recovering his status, he still has a way to go. (His last playable appearance in a main Sonic game was in Sonic 06 as one of Sonic's partners. At least Shadow had his own story.)
And even in spin-offs, Shadow shows dominince. (Sonic and the Black Knight; Tails' equivilent was a blacksmith while Shadow's was Sir Lancelot. SIR LANCELOT.)

And even now, in Sonic Generations, Tails is a sidekick, while Shadow returns as a boss.

Shadow also has his own title and Assist Trophy status in his resume. Tails has two titles for the Game Gear that were worse than what reviews make Shadow's game out to be.

But I'm not trying to be a fanboy. I genuinely beleive Tails deserves to be in SSB4. Just not before Shadow.

I would love to see both, though.


But this is off-topic. Seeing as this "roster" is without a doubt, false, this needs to be locked.

[Dettadeus]

Blah. Fine.
*locked*