The TRUE Pokemon Rumble

[Dettadeus]

Had my eyes set on this idea for a long time. When Pokemon Rumble was first announced, I thought "YES! A Pokemon Smash game!"
Then it turned out to be crap, and not even a smash game.
So, let's talk Pokemon Rumble: The real deal. Super Smash Monsters.
Post Pokemon you'd want to be on the roster. Try to be somewhat logical.

My list:
Zoroark
Darkrai
Porygon-Z
Magikarp (it splashes about, when it takes a certain amount of damage its attacks would become super-powerful explosions)
Mewtwo
Pichu Bros
Meloetta
Victini
Serperior
Breloom
Shuckle (stall until your opponent dies from toxic >=D)
Blaziken
Jigglypuff

My less logical list:
Drifloon

[El Maiz]

I'd love to see Swampert in there somewhere.
Favorite Pokemon ever.

[DGN]

GEH
I made a thing in the games factory 2 that was based on this. Cept it only was at css, had a black screen, and two mugshots of jiggs and pika.

And Mudkip should be in due to the fact of most popular pokemon, Grovyle because LEAF SAMURAI, Deoxys because he is insane, and Meowth because its obvious.
And call me biased, but Pika needs Pichu and Rai.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Pokemon Rumble was never intended to be a fighting game, let alone a Smash-styled game.
Besides, it was good. It could've been better, but still.

And I find a few of the characters suggested to not be good choices. Magikarp and Shuckle specifically.

And it needs MOAR Meowth.

[Dettadeus]

Magikarp is just the WTF character. Lots of fighting games have them, why not one with 649 characters to pick the roster from?

[StayPuft]

Pokémon Rumble is WiiWare. It isn't supposed to be a masterpiece like Super Mario Galaxy. What do you expect for like, 10 or so dollars (actually, I think Rumble is 15$, but anyway). I got the demo of Rumble and honestly I really liked it.
But anyway.
I wouldn't mind seeing a Pokémon-styled smash clone, though if you're just wanting a Pokemon fighter in general I believe that there is a street-fighter like Pokemon fighter called "Pokemon Type Wild" or something to that effect.

For this "game" or whatever:
I think all Pokemon should start as their starting evo, then as the battle lingers on and they deal damage to opponents, they gain "exp" or whatever, then they can evolve during the match.
Though that is probably getting too much out of hand.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Yes. Type:Wild. I like that.
Too bad I can't PLAY it....

And there's a difference between a WTF character and a pointless character, Detta. WTF would be someone like Game & Watch or R.O.B. in Smash, or the car in Fighters Megamix.

A better WTF would be Ditto, being able to transform into different Pokemon to attack.

[falcon8r]

I have always dreamed about having more Pokemon in Smash, or even having a Pokemon-only Smash game. It would be fun. I mean really, playing as somebody like Scizor or Gengar or Aggron would be so cool (lolololol).

Anway, enough self-aware humor. I support this.

[-Dr.MarioX-]

I SUPPORT MISSING NO.
Coming up with a balanced Pokemon Smash Bros. would be really hard though..

[GoldenYuiitusin]

*facepalm*
How could I forget Missingno. ....
THERE'S your WTF character!

[phantomhp]

he just sounds OP if anyone is. You fight him and he just hacks your system and starts deleting stuff. ok, now that's a dumb joke. Blaziken would be super cool in a smash type game but I have some problems with his new fame. Call me a hipster but I liked him before he had speed boost.

[StayPuft]

After debating, here is my list of characters that I'd put in (some bias may/will be included).
1st Gen
- Pikachu
- Gengar
- Charizard
- Squirtle
- Bulbasaur
- Mewtwo
- Mew
- Snorlax

2nd Gen
- Bayleef
- Feraligatr
- Quilava
- Espeon
- Umbreon
- Celebi
- Heracross
- Scizor

3rd Gen
- Mudkip
- Grovyle
- Blaziken
- Deoxys
- Jirachi
- Gardevoir
- Aggron
- Nuzleaf

4th Gen
- Grotle
- Infernape
- Prinplup
- Darkrai
- Lucario
- Lopunny
- Mismagius
- Floatzel

5th Gen
- Snivy
- Tepig
- Samurott
- Zoroark
- Timburr
- Victini
- Scrafty
- Tranquill