I can dream... (Daw's SSB4 roster)

[PartisanDaw]

Daw's Roster:
MARIO SERIES
1.Mario - ALT Dr.Mario
2.Luigi
3.Peach - ALT Daisy
4.Bowser
5.Bowser jr. / Shadow Mario
6.Toad
7.Yoshi
8.Wario
9.Walugi

DONKEY KONG SERIES
10.Doneky Kong
11.Didy Kong
12.K.Rool
13.Dixie Kong

THE LEGEND OF ZELDA SERIES
14.Skyward Sword Link
15.Skyward Sword Zelda / Sheik
16.Ganondorf
17. Ghirham
18.Toon Link

METROID SERIES
19.Samus / ZSS
19.Ridley
20.Dark Samus
21.Adam Malkovich

POKEMON SERIES
22.Pikachu ALT Pichu
23.Jigglypuff
24.Pokemon Trainer (Brawl) ALT Pokemon Trainer (Gold-Silver)
26.Zoroak
27.Lucario
28.Mew2

STARFOX SERIES
29.Fox
30.Falco
31.Wolf
32.? (Undecided)

F-ZERO SERIES
33.C.Falcon

EARTHBOUND
34.Ness
35.Lucas
36.Ninten or Porky

OTHERS
37.R.O.B
38.Pit
39.Marh
40.Roy
41.Ike
42.Black Knight
43.Olimar
44.Mr.G&W
45.Isaac
46.Snake
47.Sonic
48.Saki
49.Isa
50.Ryu

[DGN]

Well, you said you were dreaming(which pleases me 10-fold that you have both Saki and Isa), so I don't have anything to say, aside from Ghirahim possibly replacing Ganon.
Just have him in or don't have him in.

[PartisanDaw]

For Saki and Isa,you might be in right. 2 reps from a game that isn't so popular in Europe and USA? I might change.

Ghirahim-Edited,Hes now in like Ganon.

[DGN]

Aug 16, 2011 7:53:38 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

For Saki and Isa,you might be in right. 2 reps from a game that isn't so popular in Europe and USA? I might change.

...
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF-
(x)_(x)
Eh..........if it's not a dream roster, this should be right........but Sin and Punishment is so osm....but eh, it's only right to treat Golden sun similarly. Keep Saki and Isa if you want Isaac and Matthew, and take one out for the use of them both.
IMO, Isa is better for SSB4 because of being more well-known.

[PartisanDaw]

Edited. And suggest a FE Rep.

[sumika]

Aug 16, 2011 7:53:38 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

For Saki and Isa,you might be in right. 2 reps from a game that isn't so popular in Europe and USA? I might change.

Ghirahim-Edited,Hes now in like Ganon.

Sin and Punishment was Very Popular on VC.

Sin and Punishment 2 was Received VERY well and sold pretty damn well too. So I dont know about it being completely rubbish for one of them to get in.

[PartisanDaw]

So 2 Reps?

[Dettadeus]

Why is Mewtwo on there twice..?

[dry]

Maybe... some people liked Melee Mewtwo, and some people were disappointed. So perhaps the two Mewtwos is a failsafe solution to make sure that everyone's satisfied with Mewtwo!!!

Or it could just be a mistake.

Also, I don't like the Alts. Having alternate formes suggest that in their own games, they can transform between each other, or they are just the same person in different appearances. Peach and Daisy are DEFINITELY different characters. They would not make sense as alts. In fact, in Brawl they changed Peach's Daisy costume so that it was just a recoloring, cause people complained about the Melee one looking too much like Daisy. Same thing about Pichu and Pikachu, because Pikachu has no way to turn into a Pichu.

Popular choices for 4th star fox rep are Krystal, Slippy, Peppy and Leon.

Popular choices for 4th FE rep are Lyn, Hector, Micaiah, Caeda, Gharnef, Sephiran, Ashnard, the Black Knight, Ashera, Anri, the Shadow Dragon, and other ridiculous ones that definitely won't make it.

[DGN]

What about Lucas? He looked exactly like Claus!
Yeah.....it's not out of the ordinary to have alts...

And who would want Peppy?

[DrSlavic]

Also, by alternate forms, I believe he means that they are like Wario, which I have on my roster too. So an Alternate Costume for Mario would be Dr. Mario, etc.

[PartisanDaw]

Hmm.. My mistake about Mewtwo.

dry: You don't get it. ALT's are CLONES. In Melee,Dr.Mario was a clone and Pich was a clone.
As for the Daisy part,In Brawl,She was a recolour,But ni my eyes She's perfect for begin a ALT,like a clone.See Slavic's Reply.

As for the suggestions,I don't think Peppy would be good. Krystal is good,but I heard Golden spoke about her,that She's not going to be in/don't mach Smash.

As for FE rep's,I think SSB4 need one more vilian. (Black Knight).

[AEM]

Star Fox doesn't honestly need another rep, it seems pretty well Rep'd for now.

[PartisanDaw]

Aug 18, 2011 16:29:58 GMT -5 AEM said:

Star Fox doesn't honestly need another rep, it seems pretty well Rep'd for now.

Good that you said that. Look:
64 got Fox,Melee got Falco and Brawl got Wolf. For every new Smash game,Star fox got a new rep.

[AEM]

Aug 19, 2011 2:32:00 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Aug 18, 2011 16:29:58 GMT -5 AEM said:

Star Fox doesn't honestly need another rep, it seems pretty well Rep'd for now.

Good that you said that. Look:
64 got Fox,Melee got Falco and Brawl got Wolf. For every new Smash game,Star fox got a new rep.

I know that. But the real question is that if Star Fox NEEDS another rep? The only working Rep would be Krystal, and Sakurai would pick her over basically anyone else in the series.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Aug 19, 2011 2:32:00 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Aug 18, 2011 16:29:58 GMT -5 AEM said:

Star Fox doesn't honestly need another rep, it seems pretty well Rep'd for now.

Good that you said that. Look:
64 got Fox,Melee got Falco and Brawl got Wolf. For every new Smash game,Star fox got a new rep.

Bear in mind that Falco was added after the original roster for Melee was finished to beef it up by being a "model swap" of Fox. And that Wolf was a last minute addition in Brawl.

Just because there IS a pattern, doesn't mean you should follow it.

I notice you don't follow the 2 Pokemon per Smash pattern. Having a second Pokemon Trainer as an alt doesn't count.
And anyways, it won't serve well as an alt due to the different Pokemon. Unless it was like, the FEMALE FR/LG Trainer replacing the MALE Trainer, and Squirtle/Ivysaur/Charizard are unchanged.