AEM's SSB4 Roster Topic -UPDATED-

[AEM]

Aug 16, 2011 4:03:56 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Put a "X" over Mathew and I'm fine.

[PartisanDaw]

ME,PLASMIS AND DGN. >_>

[DGN]

Replace Matthew with Isaac,
Sukapon with IDK,
and for your misc. rep, use RISTAR ISA AMAMIYA
YUS

[y0sh1valentine]

i want lucario here (i hope so)
and no "arguments"
for this

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Aug 16, 2011 4:03:56 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Put a "X" over Mathew and I'm fine.

We cannot predict for sure whether it will be Isaac or Matthew if ANY (which I believe there won't be).
If AEM happens to believe it'd be Matthew, then who are you to tell him otherwise? It's like Zoroark and Victini; one will get in, it's just a matter of chance on which one makes it.

[PartisanDaw]

Aug 18, 2011 10:46:15 GMT -5 GoldenYuiitusin said:

Aug 16, 2011 4:03:56 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Put a "X" over Mathew and I'm fine.

We cannot predict for sure whether it will be Isaac or Matthew if ANY (which I believe there won't be).
If AEM happens to believe it'd be Matthew, then who are you to tell him otherwise? It's like Zoroark and Victini; one will get in, it's just a matter of chance on which one makes it.

But,If you look at all the facts,it's more likley to be Isaac.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Aug 19, 2011 2:34:48 GMT -5 PartisanDaw said:

Aug 18, 2011 10:46:15 GMT -5 GoldenYuiitusin said:

We cannot predict for sure whether it will be Isaac or Matthew if ANY (which I believe there won't be).
If AEM happens to believe it'd be Matthew, then who are you to tell him otherwise? It's like Zoroark and Victini; one will get in, it's just a matter of chance on which one makes it.

But,If you look at all the facts,it's more likley to be Isaac.

You mean like how Ninten was added?

There is no "more likely" character. Between the two it's 50/50.
Or in my opinion, it's 0/0, as I seriously doubt a GS character at this point, but that's just me.

[AEM]

I was bored, so I remade the roster, however I have 58 on this one. I added some, I removed some.

I'm going to remake it in the style I did for GY, so yeah just wait and see.

[AEM]

Front Page Update

Check it out.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Aug 11, 2011 4:47:34 GMT -5 AEM said:

Got questions? I will answer them.

Ok, I will grade them by row.

1. The Mario Row: Can't really complain about this. All characters are very likely. Although I see where you're going with putting Toad next to Peach, and Bowser next to Jr., the nitpicky side of me is bugging me that the order isn't Veterans followed by Newcomers. Don't let that influence you though. 10/10.

2. The Mario Related Row: Again, solid choices. Although, I DO find having Mario, Dr. Mario (even if he IS an alt), AND Paper Mario to be a bit excessive, as would many fans. Also, I don't understand why D.I.Y. Wario is an alt and not regular WarioWare Wario. 9/10.

3. The Zelda Row: I'm a bit irked you didn't use THAT image of Ganondorf for my Roster, but whatevs. Solid choices again. 10/10.

4. The "Theme of No Theme" Row: Good choices. I am doubting Little Mac and any GS character, but that's just me. 10/10.

5. The Cutesy Row: Meh, not too big on Starfy. Everyone else is fine. Except for Olimar being AFTER Starfy 9/10.

6. The Driver Row: Pretty much like mine, except it has Goroh instead of Black Shadow, and Excitebiker instead of Mach Rider. While I do respect that some would prefer Goroh over BS, Excitebiker is definitely NOT my cup of tea. Sakurai also said no to him. 9/10.

7. The POGEYMANS Pokemon Row: Ignoring my displeasure of seeing Meowth instead of Lucario for a second, I notice that he's in Mewtwo's spot, and Mewtwo's in Meowth's. Mewtwo was a Melee veteran and must be treated as such to where he is not AFTER a Brawl veteran. Now back to my displeasure of seeing Meowth instead of Lucario. Just.....WHY?
I'm sorry, but just for Lucario being axed in favor of Meowth: 6/10.

8. The RPG Row: Same exact version as mine. 10/10. As you told me on Xat, this was an error. Roy's not in, and instead you have Porky. My gripes with that. 1. Mother should NOT have more characters than Fire Emblem. EVER. 2. Roy is a Melee veteran, and you brought back PICHU (who wasn't planned for Brawl) but not Roy (who WAS). Also, Roy is HEAVILY wanted to return by fans worldwide, and practically DEBUTED in Smash, thereby giving Smash it's own character. Also, of the Mother characters, Masked Man is the most requested, and would have the biggest shot over Porky. 6/10.

9. The Retro Row: These are all good, unique choices, but I feel that this is just too many Retro characters. 8/10.

10. The Others Row: Solid choices. Also irked that THAT image of Snake wasn't used on mine, but again, whatevs. Mii is a very interesting idea indeed. I'm confused though on how it should work, so I don't have it on my Roster. 10/10.

Total: 78/100.

[AEM]

So in other words

DAMN YOU MEOWTH AND PORKY


HUURRRR


And you know what Roy over Porky, so yeah gimme my Ten back.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Alright, Revised RPG Row score: 10/10.

Revised Total: 82/100.

And because Roy's back in:
"You went through the trouble to bring back every Melee vet in some way (except for Young Link, as Toon is the new Young), and you cut a Brawl one? One that wasn't a clone? In favor of a character that has less than 20% chance?"

[AEM]

Aug 30, 2011 0:03:14 GMT -5 GoldenYuiitusin said:

Alright, Revised RPG Row score: 10/10.

Revised Total: 82/100.

And because Roy's back in:
"You went through the trouble to bring back every Melee vet in some way (except for Young Link, as Toon is the new Young), and you cut a Brawl one? One that wasn't a clone? In favor of a character that has less than 20% chance?"

I
FREAKING
HATE
YOU


;-;


OH, and Zoroark replaced Lucario

:3

[GoldenYuiitusin]

Again, why?

Lucario has an original moveset, has great popularity, is STILL relevant (You can fight Cynthia in B/W, and she still has her Lucario). Pichu (who you brought BACK) may have been axed in favor of Lucario, but remember that Pichu was a clone, and the least popular one at that.
Axing Lucario will have the same result as when Mewtwo was axed from Brawl. Do you really want that?

Besides, you have a character that has less than 20% chance (Meowth) instead of him. You have room for Lucario, you just don't want to give up the pointless character.
I mean, I don't have Shadow the Hedgehog or Shake King on my Roster, and I REAAAALLY want them playable.

[DGN]

Right there, right on.
I mean, seriously. Meowth is NOT necessary. You also appear to want them at 6 reps for the main characters. Had you not wanted to set a limit of 5(like me), you would have to have Lucario up there.

Also. Who's the guy with the bat in the Retro area? And is that Muddy Mole or whatever right next to him?

[GoldenYuiitusin]

The one with the bat is Mike Jones from the classic StarTropics series.
And yes, that is Muddy Mole.

[AEM]

Should probably have mentioned that this is the EXTENSIVE ROSTER, meaning it has more about 9 more characters then the ACTUAL one, so yeah. Allow me to update the first post pointing out who are the Extensive Exclusives.

[GoldenYuiitusin]

MEWTWO is on the Extensive, not MEOWTH?

WTH?

[AEM]

UPDATED ONCE MORE

This roster does not contain the extensive fighters.
It has some changes, the biggest one is seen in the second row.


May the complaints begin.

[DrSlavic]

This roster looks muy good. I have no complaints with the exception of the Mii. I don't think he fits in a crossover fighting game. That's all. I especially like Muddy Mole and Andy.